Aug 29, 2015 we asked the pentagon to explain their new law of war manual and what it means for journalists covering wars. The pentagon s massive new law of war manual drew criticism from the new york times editorial board on monday for its section on how to treat journalists, which the times said would make. Jun 25, 2015 the pentagon has released a book of instructions on the law of war, detailing acceptable ways of killing the enemy. Francis boyle who wrote the biological weapons antiterrorism act of 1989, the american implementing. Pentagon revises law of war manual after criticism of press treatment. Pentagon revamps law of war manual to protect journalists. The pentagon on friday updated its law of war manual after a previous version came under fire for appearing to allow commanders to treat journalists as belligerents or spies. The description appears in a 1,176page, richly footnoted department of defense law of war manual that tells commanders the right and wrong way to kill the enemy. Today, the department of defense has issued the firstever dodwide law of war manual. The manual is meant to dictate legal conduct for service members from all branches during military operations. Bushera label of unlawful enemy combatant for al qaeda and the like. The manual is a guide for dod personnel responsible for implementing the law of war.
New pentagon manual declares journalists can be enemy. The pentagon released an updated version of it law of war manual on friday after receiving criticism that the current guidelines allowed commanders to question the. Published on jun 23, 2015 the manual pushes aside the george w. Charles allen, a pentagon lawyer, told bob garfield, the cohost of the national public radio show on the media, that department officials are taking public comments into account to make updates to guidelines in the document that spells out the pentagon s view of the law of armed conflict. Last friday, the department of defense released an update to the 2015 law of war manual. Reuters the pentagon on friday updated its law of war manual after a previous version came under fire for appearing to allow commanders to treat journalists as belligerents or spies.
Aug 11, 2015 the pentagon has adopted a law of war manual pdf, which enables commanders to treat journalists as unprivileged belligerents. The united states department ofldefense law of war manual. The manual is a guide for dod personnel responsible for implementing the law of war and executing military operations. Pentagon war manual gives military license to attack journalists. The manual, first released in 2015, is the department of defenses.
Countercurrentnewsthe pentagon just changed the rules of war to include legitimizing the killing of any journalists they deem belligerent. The most menacing passages of the pentagons law of war manual concern its relationship to other areas of law. George washington, as commander in chief of the continental army, agreed with his british adversary that the revolutionary war would be carried on agreeable to the rules which humanity formed and to. Jan 06, 2016 the law of war manual, which elaborates protocols for military operations in every corner of the globe by the pentagon and its proxy forces, amounts to a manifesto for this process, set down in legal jargon. Manual authorizes slaughter of innocent civilians because according to boyle the manual allows massacres of civilian populations.
Jun 25, 2015 countercurrentnewsthe pentagon just changed the rules of war to include legitimizing the killing of any journalists they deem belligerent. The pentagon has released a book of instructions on the law of war, detailing acceptable ways of killing the enemy. According to charlie savage of the new york times, the changes mainly center on the section related to the treatment of journalists in conflict. Pentagon manual calls for potentially treating journalists like unprivileged belligerents. Pentagons new law of war manual justifies war crimes and.
Jun 21, 2015 the pentagons law of war manual was released by department of defense general counsel stephen w. Preston, who said the thick booklet represents many years of labor and expertise. And its worth noting, too, that the defense departments law of war manual issued in 2015 has a chapter on the subject see ch. The united states department of defense law of war manual edited by michael a. The best way to think about last weeks speech by defense department general counsel paul c.
The changes, announced last week, came after media groups expressed concern that some language in the original version could put reporters at risk of being considered spies or combatants. This manual is a department of defense dodwide resource for dod personnel including commanders, legal practitioners, and other military and civilian personnel on the law of war. An important function of the 2015 dod law of war manual has been to address longstanding confusion concerning the u. Jul 22, 2016 pentagon revises law of war manual after criticism of press treatment the old u. The manual is so bad that one of the leading experts on the law of war dr. Jul 22, 2016 the 2015 version of the pentagons law of war manual, which provides guidelines for members of the u.
If the guidelines laid out in the manual are allowed to be implementedthat is, if the international working class does not intervene in. The 1,165page document, dated june 2015 department of defense law of war manual, is not a statement of existing law as much as a compendium of what the pentagon wishes the law to be. Part two a recipe for total war and military dictatorship by tom carter 4 november 2015 part one part two part three part four. Pentagon officials updated some sections of the 2015 manual in response to the concerns expressed by the media groups. Part one a blueprint for total war and military dictatorship by tom carter 3 november 2015 the new us department of defense law of war manual is essentially a guidebook for violating international and domestic law and committing war crimes. The new us department of defense law of war manual is essentially a guidebook for violating international and domestic law and committing war crimes. The pentagon s new law of war manual a 1,200plus page document issued in june by the defense departments office of the general counsel is barbaric the manual is so bad that one of the leading experts on the law of war dr. According to the manual, the law of war is separate from and supersedes all other bodies of law, including international human rights treaties and the united states constitutions bill of rights. The law of military occupation applies when a military occupation exists in fact.
It suggests that correspondents who report some information about combat operations may be taking direct part in hostilities, a disturbing argument for justifying the killing of reporters in war zones. Law of war manual december 2016 open pdf 12 mb this document is the updated version of the department of defense law of war manual. Pentagon revises law of war manual after criticism of. The 2015 version of the pentagon s law of war manual, which provides guidelines for members of the u. Will the pentagon change its manual on the law of war. The pentagon has updated its law of war manual to clarify that journalists are generally protected as civilians under international law. Pentagon alters law of war manual to remove suggestion that. Aug 19, 2015 the pentagon came out with their law of war document that says journalists are civilians, the us can use expanding ammunition and depleted uranium in there weapons. Pentagons revised law of war manual recognizes role of. Transcend media service the pentagons law of war manual. Significantly, following its publication in june 2015, dod has continued to. The new laws of war were released as part of a book of instructions on legitimate warfare practices approved by the united states military. Aug 18, 2015 the pentagons law of war manual, published in june, says journalists may be censored to stop them from revealing information to the enemy.
Pentagon expands journalist protections in revised law of war. The pentagons general counsel on the law of military. The pentagons law of war manual, published in june, says journalists may be censored to stop them from revealing information to the enemy. Department of defense law of war manual liberty blitzkrieg. Jul 22, 2016 pentagon officials had said the 2015 manuals reference to unprivileged belligerents was intended to point out that terrorists or spies could be masquerading as reporters. Dod announces update to the dod law of war manual u. Today, the department of defense released an update to the 2015 law of war manual. Jul 22, 2016 the pentagon on friday updated its law of war manual after a previous version came under fire for appearing to allow commanders to treat journalists as belligerents or spies. Part two a recipe for total war and military dictatorship by tom carter 4 november 2015 this is the second of four articles analyzing the new us department of defense law of war manual. The law of war manual, which elaborates protocols for military operations in every corner of the globe by the pentagon and its proxy forces, amounts to a manifesto for this process, set down in legal jargon. We asked the pentagon to explain their new law of war manual and what it means for journalists covering wars.
Pentagon revises war manual to emphasize protections for. Pentagon officials had said the 2015 manual s reference to unprivileged belligerents was intended to point out that terrorists or spies could be masquerading as reporters. As savage notes, when the manual was released last year, journalists and activists raised objections to this. The dod law of war manual and its critics duke law scholarship. Pentagon war manual gives military license to target and. The updated dod law of war manual and the precaution of military. Thanks to matthijs koot for bringing this to our attention office of general counsel department of defense. The manual also states that journalists can be labeled unprivileged belligerents, an obscure term that replaced enemy combatant. This law of war manual reduces us to the level of nazis. By claire bernish in activist post just when it seemed the governments policy language couldnt get any more paradoxical, selfjustifying, and replete with inconsistencies, the pentagon issued its law of war manual earlier this month. Indeed, two major nationalinternational security law focused blogs, just security3 and lawfare,4 created.
The 1,165page document, dated june 2015 and recently made available online, is not a statement of existing law as much as a compendium of what the pentagon wishes the law to be. Dec 22, 2015 in june 2015, the united states published its first ever department of defense law of war manual, with a separate chapter on cyber operations and several other innovations compared. A 1,176 page pentagon war manual was recently released that hasnt received the attention it deserves. The 1,165page document, dated june 2015 and recently. Pentagon just legalized killing belligerent journalists as. Francis boyle who wrote the biological weapons antiterrorism act of 1989, the american implementing legislation for the 1972 biological weapons convention, served on the board of directors of amnesty international, and teaches international law at the university. Aug 29, 2015 what the pentagons law of war manual means for conflict reporting. Jul 23, 2016 pentagon revamps law of war manual to protect journalists an agence francepresse reporter hit the ground as a syrian soldier ran past him during sniper fire in the town of maaloula in 20. In 2015, 199 journalists were being detained worldwide, compared to 221 in 2014.
The most menacing passages of the pentagon s law of war manual concern its relationship to other areas of law. Part four a recipe for total war and military dictatorship by thomas gaist 6 november 2015 part one part two part three part four. The pentagon s new law of war manual a 1,200plus page document issued in june by the defense departments office of the general counsel is barbaric. The pentagons rules of media engagement usa al jazeera. Pentagon manual calls some reporters spies consortiumnews. The department of defense announces update to the law of war. Even if the requirements of the law of belligerent occupation do not apply as a matter of law, general law of war principles and rules, such as those for the conduct of hostilities, continue to apply. The manual is the product of a multiyear effort by military and civilian lawyers from across. The pentagon s law of war manual was released by department of defense general counsel stephen w. Human shields one of the most energetic and derisive of the manual s early critics is pro fessor adil ahmad haque of rutgers university newark school of law. The pentagon released its first departmentofdefensewide law of war manual in june 2015. Pentagon just legalized killing belligerent journalists. The pentagons law of war manual a blueprint for total.
Jan 04, 2016 the new us department of defense law of war manual is essentially a guidebook for violating international and domestic law and committing war crimes. In june 2015, the united states published its first ever department of defense law of war manual, with a separate chapter on cyber operations and several other innovations compared. The pentagon responds we asked the pentagon to explain their new law of war manual and what it means for journalists covering wars. Pentagon revises its rules to clarify protections for. The 1,165page document is not a statement of existing law as much as a compendium of what the pentagon wishes the law to be. Pentagon revamps law of war manual to protect journalists an agence francepresse reporter hit the ground as a syrian soldier ran past him during. Pentagon s new law of war manual justifies war crimes and censorship episode 745b.
Department of defense manual compared some of the tasks of journalism to spying or other hostile actions by an enemy. The pentagon s law of war manual, published in june, says. Nprs on the media set down with pentagon press secretary peter cook. The pentagons law of war manual a blueprint for total war. The manual advises journalists to do their job openly, with the authorization of relevant authorities, because it says reporting can be similar to gathering intelligence. Dec, 2016 today, the department of defense released an update to the law of war manual. Dod announces new law of war manual june 12, 2015 today, the department of defense has issued the firstever dodwide law of war manual. The obama administrations war on the press could become a.
Pentagon revises law of war manual after criticism. Pentagon war manual gives military license to attack. Department of defense law of war manual june 2015 public. The pentagons law of war for cyberspace the diplomat. International law studies 2016 87 the lex lata of the law of war. Ernesto londono, will the pentagon change its manual on the law of war. Pentagon alters law of war manual to remove suggestion. Pentagon revises law of war manual after criticism of press.
Jun 12, 2015 dod announces new law of war manual june 12, 2015 today, the department of defense has issued the firstever dodwide law of war manual. The manual advises journalists to do their job openly. Pentagon revises law of war manual to for suggestion. Honest war correspondents and photographers who try to cover wars effectively are about to become suspect spies if a new pentagon manual, law of war, is accepted by u.
Pentagon releases law of war manual ya oughtalearn. Military reporters and editors group wants law of war. What the pentagon s law of war manual means for conflict reporting. The 2015 version of the pentagons law of war manual, which provides guidelines for members of the u. The revised section states that in general, journalists are civilians and are protected as such under the law of war. Jun 27, 2015 by claire bernish in activist post just when it seemed the governments policy language couldnt get any more paradoxical, selfjustifying, and replete with inconsistencies, the pentagon issued its law of war manual earlier this month.
1506 758 614 1220 1391 826 919 134 1311 1121 136 1367 507 828 989 1464 437 557 1490 1320 776 1493 105 552 657 20 105 563 1221 562 273 752 870 727 64 1420 38 573 464 815 1090 821 1156 1058 866